top of page
Search

Before You Say Yes: 7 Questions to Ask Your Interviewer

11 minutes ago
5 min read

How to spot warning signs and get a clearer picture of the culture you could be stepping into


The interview went well. The role sounds exciting. You can already picture yourself handing in your notice.


But before you accept, there’s another question to answer: what would it actually feel like to work here?


A job description can tell you what you’ll do. An interview should help you understand how you’ll be supported, what success will require and what happens when things get difficult.


No interview gives you full visibility into a workplace. But thoughtful questions and a little attention to how people answer them, can help you make a more informed decision.



Here are seven worth asking.


1. “Why is this role available, and what have you learned from the person who held it previously?”


This helps you understand the story behind the vacancy. Is the team growing? Has someone been promoted? Or has the position been difficult to fill and keep filled?


If it’s a new role, ask what prompted its creation and whether its responsibilities and resources have been agreed.


Listen for: A clear explanation of why the role exists, realistic expectations and thoughtful reflection on what could work better.


Watch for: Blaming the previous employee, avoiding reasonable questions about turnover or describing a succession of people who “couldn’t handle the pace”.

A useful follow-up: “What will be different for the next person stepping into the role?”



2. “What would success look like in the first three and six months?”


“Hit the ground running” can sound energising. It’s less appealing when it means delivering immediate results without training, clear priorities or access to the right people.


This question helps you test whether the organisation has a realistic picture of what you can achieve and what it needs to provide.


Listen for: Specific priorities, a sensible learning period and clarity about who will help you get established.


Watch for: Everything being urgent, conflicting expectations or an extensive list of outcomes with little mention of onboarding.


A useful follow-up: “If those priorities compete, who decides what comes first?”


3. “Can you share a recent example of how the team handled a mistake or a disagreement?”


Most organisations say they value openness. A real example tells you more about what happens when someone raises a concern, challenges a decision or gets something wrong.


You’re looking for evidence that people can speak honestly and take responsibility without being humiliated.


Listen for: An example that explains what happened, how people responded and what changed afterwards.


Watch for: Claims that disagreements never happen, jokes about difficult employees or a story focused entirely on who was at fault.


A useful follow-up: “What happened after the person raised the issue?”



4. “When the workload exceeds the team’s capacity, what happens?”


Asking whether a workplace is “busy” rarely tells you much. Asking how it manages pressure gets closer to the reality of working there.


Busy periods can happen. The important part is whether leaders make choices about deadlines, staffing and scope or expect employees to absorb the difference indefinitely.

Listen for: Examples of reprioritising work, moving deadlines, adding support or deciding what won’t get done.


Watch for: Constant availability framed as commitment, pride in routinely working late or “we all just pitch in” without any explanation of limits.


A useful follow-up: “When did you last reduce or delay work to protect the team’s capacity?”


5. “How does the manager support people, give feedback and respond when someone needs help?”


Your relationship with your manager will shape much of your day-to-day experience. Find out what their management approach looks like in practice.


Support doesn’t mean constant oversight. It means knowing what’s expected, receiving useful feedback and being able to get help when you need it.


Listen for: Regular conversations, clear expectations and examples of adapting support to different people.


Watch for: Feedback arriving only when something goes wrong, a manager who is routinely unavailable or “I hire good people and leave them alone” without further explanation.


A useful follow-up: “Could you give me an example of how you helped someone through a challenge?”



6. “What does flexibility look like in practice for this team?”


A policy is a starting point. Your potential team’s habits will tell you more about how usable it is.


Whether flexibility means hybrid work, adjusted hours or taking time for an appointment, ask about the arrangements that matter to you. You don’t need to disclose personal circumstances to understand the expectations.


Listen for: Clear answers about working hours, attendance, availability and how arrangements are agreed.


Watch for: “We’re flexible, but…” followed by unclear conditions, different answers from different interviewers or suggestions that visibility matters more than results.

A useful follow-up: “How do people on this team currently use that flexibility?”


If an arrangement is essential to your decision, ask for it to be confirmed in writing before accepting.


7. “What tends to surprise new starters, and what do people find hardest about working here?”


Every workplace has challenges. You’re looking for enough honesty to judge whether its challenges are ones you’re willing to take on.


This gives the interviewer an opportunity to move beyond the sales pitch and describe the less polished parts of the job.


Listen for: A candid answer with enough detail to help you assess the trade-off and a clear distinction between a temporary problem and an ongoing feature of the role.


Watch for: An inability to name any challenges, dismissing concerns as attitude problems or presenting persistent understaffing as an exciting opportunity.


A useful follow-up: “Could I speak with someone who would be a peer in the team about their experience?”



Pay attention to the answers and the response to being asked


You don’t have to work through all seven questions in one sitting. Choose the ones that matter most to you and build on what you hear.


Ask for examples when an answer feels vague. Where possible, explore the same topic with your future manager and a potential colleague. Differences may have a reasonable explanation, but they’re worth understanding before you commit.

One awkward answer isn’t a verdict. Look for patterns: repeated evasiveness, inconsistent expectations or a reluctance to discuss ordinary working conditions.


Before accepting, ask yourself:

  • Do I understand what will be expected of me?

  • Have I heard examples of how people are supported?

  • Are the working arrangements clear?

  • Can I make an informed choice about the trade-offs?


You may not find a workplace with every box ticked. But you deserve enough information to decide whether the opportunity fits your needs, values and life.

The interview is your chance to assess them, too.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page